Margarita in a Can: What's Really Inside, and the Better Way to Bring One

By Jason LaValla, founder, Casamara Club · September 2026

Jump to: What's in most canned margaritas · The tell on the label · One can, every strength · Tequilas bartenders are recommending · Ours · FAQ · Sources

A margarita in a can is a good idea. A cold one at the lake, a four-pack for the people who show up late, no shaker. The problem is what the can usually holds. We make a non-alcoholic margarita, so the last section is ours and says so. Everything before it is the guide we would want in the aisle.

The short answer: "Margarita" on a can does not mean tequila is in it. Canned margaritas are built on one of three bases, a malt beverage, an agave or grape wine, or a spirit, and only the last contains tequila; when it does, the label rarely says "100% agave," which means a mixto, and sugar and flavoring cover the difference. The better move is a non-alcoholic margarita like Superclasico Margarita plus a bottle of 100% agave blanco you chose yourself: everyone at the table sets their own strength, from none to about 8% ABV, with a tequila a bartender would pour.

What's in most canned margaritas

Three different drinks share the word "margarita" on a can, and the front does not say which one you are holding; the drinks blog 12x75 and Chowhound make the point independently.

Malt-based. The alcohol comes from fermented grain, a flavored beer in structure; flavors, sweeteners, and acids push it toward a margarita. Chowhound gives the reason: malt is taxed at a lower rate than distilled spirits, and a neutral base lets sweeteners and juice carry the flavor. The inference that this is why tequila gets left out is ours.

Agave-wine and wine-based. Agave wine starts with fermented agave and never goes through the distillation that makes tequila. It sits in the wine category, which is taxed and distributed differently from spirits, and it is already the base for plenty of margarita-style drinks in cans and bottles. One national producer lists its whole margarita range as "agave wine with natural flavors," 12.5% ABV in cans and 13.9% in bottles. "Agave" on a can is a plant. It is not tequila.

Spirit-based. The smallest group and the only one that contains tequila. 12x75's reading of US labeling rules is that a spirit-based can must communicate the spirit or composition on the label, which is why "made with tequila" appears on this group and not the others. The tequila is a mixto unless the can says "100% agave": at least 51% of the fermentable sugars came from agave, the rest from cane or corn, and the agave character is quieter for it. Our read of the aisle, not a measured fact: when a can does contain tequila, it is rarely 100% agave and rarely named, and sugar and "natural flavors" do the spirit's work.

US alcoholic beverages are not required to list ingredients, so on most cans the class statement and the ABV are all you get. Tasting Table's panel tasted the result: a widely sold sparkling can "reminds us of sparkling limeade."

The tell on the label

Turn the can around. The front is marketing; the back is evidence, and five lines there answer everything.

1. The base. "Malt beverage," "agave wine," "grape wine," or "made with tequila." That phrase is the family of drink you are buying.
2. 100% agave, or not. No "100% agave" or "100% de agave" means mixto.
3. ABV and can size, together. A US standard drink is 0.6 fl oz of pure alcohol. A 12 oz can at 5.9% holds about 1.2 standard drinks; at 12.5%, about 2.5. The can is the package, not the serving.
4. Lime juice, or "natural flavors." Real lime juice is listed as lime juice; many cans use citric acid instead, and "natural lime flavor" may never have met a lime.
5. Sugar, and what kind. Nutrition disclosure on alcohol is voluntary, so many cans show nothing. Where a "skinny" version does show a panel, the sugar has been swapped for sucralose, with certified colors alongside.

The longer guide to these panels is Canned Mocktails, Explained.

One can, every strength

The best margarita in a can has no tequila in it, because the tequila is the one thing the drinker should get to choose. The can fixes the lime, the sweetness, the orange, and the bitterness; the pour fixes the strength. One four-pack serves the friend who is driving, the friend who wants one long drink, and the friend who wants a proper margarita. Superclasico Margarita is non-alcoholic; the numbers below describe the drink after you add tequila, nothing about the can.

The arithmetic, so you can redo it for your own pour: 40% tequila carries 0.4 oz of alcohol per ounce; divide alcohol by total volume for ABV, and by 0.6 for standard drinks.

The canned margaritas we found listed run from 5.9% ABV in a 12 oz can to 12.5% in a can and 13.9% in a bottle, so the 1½ oz build lands where the lightest cans do and the 2 oz build well under the strongest, with a tequila you picked. Classic, frozen, and pitcher margaritas are worked out in How Much Alcohol Is in a Margarita?.

How to build it

Start with tequila and ice at the bottom of your favorite small, unfussy glassware. Pour the Margarita down the wall of the glass, not directly over the ice. Superclasico comes in 8oz cans only, and they will do just fine. Salt the rim if you go that way, and garnish with a lime wheel. For a crowd, grab a pitcher. We think the Margarita mixes particularly well with blanco tequila.

More builds are on our recipes page; glassware and pour notes are in How to Serve Casamara Club.

Tequilas bartenders are recommending for margaritas

Blanco, 100% agave, and additive-free where you can confirm it: that is the consensus across PUNCH's bartender survey, VinePair's panel of 25 bartenders, and The Kitchn's three, who "unanimously agreed" on blanco from highland agave. The bottles below were named by at least two of those sources, with the reason and price each gave; they are third-party recommendations, not ours. Two VinePair bartenders reach for a reposado in spirit-forward drinks, and PUNCH's list includes one mixto its panel finds agave-forward anyway.

On "additive-free," a caution. Under current tequila rules a bottle can carry up to 1% of approved additives, glycerin, sweeteners, oak extract, caramel color, and still say "100% agave." VinePair's Roderick Williams: most any bottle that is "100 percent Blue Agave and is additive-free is going to be good for mixing." But the phrase is contested. In October 2024 the Consejo Regulador de Tequila threatened brands over "additive free" language, and the Tequila Matchmaker app, since renamed Agave Matchmaker, removed every additive-free designation from its database in response, and the dispute was still running in 2026. Treat "additive-free" as a bartender's word for a production style, not a certification on a label.

Ours

Superclasico Margarita is a non-alcoholic margarita in an 8 oz can, coming soon, with Notify Me on the product page. Ingredients: Sparkling Water, Lime Juice, Blue Agave Syrup, with Extracts of Blue Agave, Lime Peel, Gentian, Valencia Orange, Seville Orange, Apricot, Peppermint, Orange Blossom, and Ceylon Cinnamon. Per 8 fl oz can: 40 calories, 10 g carbohydrate, 9 g sugars. Against the checklist: sparkling water and real lime juice, the sugar named, the flavor a list of extracts you can read, and no tequila in it until you decide there should be.

In our words: a celebration of dry curacao and blue agave, lime peel and Seville orange up front, Valencia orange and apricot through the middle, gentian and Ceylon cinnamon on the finish. In our tasting it gives the can a bitter edge at zero and keeps it from reading as lime soda once the tequila goes in. Sold in 12-can packs and up. The landing page is Non-Alcoholic Margarita; the mix comparison is in the margarita mix guide.

Coming soon

Superclasico Margarita

Blue Agave & Orange Curaçao

Just over the Rio Grande. Doors propped open, neon buzzing.

Get notified when it's available →

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Does a canned margarita have tequila in it?

A: Often not. Many are malt beverages or agave-wine cocktails flavored like a margarita; only spirit-based ones contain tequila; the class statement on the back says which.

Q: What is a mixto tequila?

A: A tequila in which at least 51% of the fermentable sugars come from agave and the rest from cane or corn. Mixtos are labeled simply "tequila"; a bottle that does not say "100% agave" is one. The agave notes are quieter.

Q: How much alcohol is in a canned margarita?

A: The listings we found run from 5.9% to 12.5% ABV in cans, and 13.9% in bottles; a 12 oz can at those strengths holds roughly 1.2 to 2.5 standard drinks.

Q: Can I make a canned margarita stronger or weaker?

A: A premixed alcoholic one, only weaker, by diluting it. A non-alcoholic margarita, both directions: one 8 oz can of Superclasico Margarita plus 1 oz of 40% tequila is about 4.4% ABV, two-thirds of a standard drink; 2 oz is 8% and 1⅓. The figures describe the mixed drink, not the can.

Q: What tequila goes in a margarita?

A: Blanco and 100% agave, from about $20 up; the bottles bartenders name most often are in the table above. We think the Margarita mixes particularly well with blanco tequila.

Q: Is a non-alcoholic margarita just margarita mix?

A: No. A mix is a concentrate meant to be diluted by tequila and ice; thin and sweet on its own. A non-alcoholic margarita is a finished, carbonated drink built to be poured as is, with the bitterness and structure a spirit would supply already in the can. The detail is in our margarita mix guide.

Sources

• PUNCH, "The Best Tequila for Margaritas, According to Bartenders" (July 26, 2024): punchdrink.com/articles/best-tequila-margarita-cocktail/
• VinePair, "We Asked 25 Bartenders: What's the Best Tequila for Mixing Cocktails?" (2024): vinepair.com/articles/wa-bartenders-best-tequila-for-cocktails-2024/
• The Kitchn, "We Asked 3 Bartenders to Name the Best Tequila for a Margarita" (May 23, 2024): thekitchn.com/best-tequila-for-margaritas-23660306
• 12x75, "Best Tequila for Margaritas 2026" (July 2026): 12x75.com/best-tequila-for-margaritas/
• VinePair, "Tequila Matchmaker Removes All Tequila Brands From Its Additive-Free List" (October 21, 2024): vinepair.com/articles/tequila-matchmaker-removes-additive-free-list/ ; tequilamatchmaker.com now redirects to agavematchmaker.com (checked September 7, 2026)
• 12x75, "What Is Actually Inside a Canned Cocktail? (Read the Can)" (updated August 2026; independent blog, its TTB characterizations are secondary-sourced): 12x75.com/what-is-inside-a-canned-cocktail/
• Chowhound, "The Ingredients to Look for in a Quality Canned Margarita" (January 31, 2024): chowhound.com/1501875/best-ingredients-for-quality-canned-margarita/
• Tasting Table, "11 Popular Canned Margaritas, Ranked" (February 2023; ABV figures 8%, 11%, 12.5%, "just under 6%"; the "sparkling limeade" quote): tastingtable.com/1206515/popular-canned-margaritas-ranked/
• BevMo product listing, Cazadores Margarita 12 oz can, 5.9% ABV: bevmo.com/products/66453
• Rancho La Gloria product information ("agave wine with natural flavors"; 12.5% ABV cans, 13.9% ABV bottles; 9.9% "skinny" with sucralose and certified colors): rancholagloria.com/productinfo/
• Liberation Cocktails (UK), Spicy Margarita 150 ml can, ingredients "tequila mixto, lime, chilli & agave nectar," 10% ABV: liberationcocktails.com/products/spiced-margarita-in-a-can
• NIAAA, "What Is a Standard Drink?" (0.6 fl oz pure alcohol): niaaa.nih.gov/alcohols-effects-health/alcohol-topics/alcohol-facts-and-statistics/what-standard-drink
• Difford's Guide, Tequila classifications (mixto, 100% agave, blanco): diffordsguide.com/g/1084/tequila/classifications

Find Casamara Club at casamaraclub.com. Ships to all 50 states.

For restaurant wholesale inquiries: sales@casamaraclub.com